Category: Research

ROGUEHAA PUBLISHED IN MONU #15 – “CHOOSE YOUR OWN URBANISM”

Tuesday, December 27th, 2011


This new MONU issue on the topic of Post-Ideological Urbanism probably touches on one of the most fascinating and biggest issues of our time and in our culture, or what is left of it: the non-ideological – or better post-ideological – conditions of our society when it comes to cities. Today, ideology ap…pears to have become, and to have been reduced to, something merely aesthetic, something you can buy yourself into as Wouter Vanstiphout explains in an interview with us entitled “Acrobatic Narratives”. In that sense cities have become suspicious territories where hypocrisy and fakery prevail when it comes to urban ideologies…and a new sincerity is obviously needed in a world consisting of a multiplicity of choices and urban outcomes without a single consistent urban ideology as Melissa Dittmer, Jamie Witherspoon, and Noah Resnick point out in their piece “Choose Your Own Urbanism Presents: The Case of the Missing Ideal”.

The following text is an excerpt from an article entitled “CHOOSE YOUR OWN URBANISM PRESENTS: The Case of the Missing Ideal” that has been recently published in the latest MONU magazine:

It’s a hot, dry and dusty afternoon… But, then again, all the afternoons are hot, dry and dusty in Sin City.  You’re in your shoebox of an office with the top three buttons of your white cotton shirt undone, a damp towel on the back of your neck, and the sound of a rickety two-dollar fan blowing in your face.  The A.C. is on the fritz again, and you’re just about to phone up that good-for-nothing building super to complain, when you hear three soft taps on the glass pane of your office door – the one that reads: Calvin Lynch, Private Detective.

You ask her to have a seat in the worn leather armchair and offer her a cigarette and a glass of flat ginger ale.  She accepts neither and says she prefers to stand. 

“I’m searching for something,” she finally says, after standing in front of the window, staring out through the half-closed blinds. “They say what happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas, but this thing didn’t stay.  Or, maybe it never existed to begin with. Either way, I need your help.”

(more…)

ARCHITECT AS IMPOSTER

Monday, March 7th, 2011


Las Vegas – The Double Agent.  Las Vegas has always been a city of conflicted identities.   The Strip, faux-velvet pastiche was built on the dreams of images and illusion. The Desert, the extreme of a ‘natural’, harsh, untouched world exists as both silent background but also as an essential part of the Vegas experience – two conflicting constructed realities simultaneously superimposed on one another. Both identities of Las Vegas exist as totalizing worlds, literally and conceptually distinct from one another, yet occupying the same physical space.  A bi-polar existence blatantly marketed to the world. 

False DocumentsArchitects increasingly use the perspectival rendering as a way to convey experiential narrative and to portray a space ‘as it will be.’ These images are never about reality, but when used as tools to convey a certain idealized vision, they create a portal into a counterfeit world.  In every design proposal, there are certain embedded cultural practices, biases, and stereotypes which inevitably influence how future inhabitants will understand and occupy these spaces. And regardless of the intentions, hyper-“realism” renderings dictate future interactions between people and their internal and external environments.  (more…)

MILANO<>DETROIT : DENSE<>RARIFIED

Wednesday, January 19th, 2011

 

“Two cities and two themes: voids and density.  In one city, voids have been expressly created, in the other, the voids are the result of decline.  In one, voids are defined by the surrounding density, in the other, the empty spaces neither define nor are defined.  Milan and Detroit have very little in common.  Indeed they seem opposites, like positive and negative images of the same picture.”  -Maurizio Sabini

In the latest edition of the Italian design journal, THE PLAN, two editors compile an assortment of city specific urban design articles.  Milan’s essays illustrate the extreme densification of their Italian city and the deliberate insertion of strategically programmed voids.  While the Detroit contributors expand upon the current dynamic state of this city, urban creativity resulting from the many voids of Detroit, and the need to redefine the previously negative connotations of Detroit as void

Hamilton Anderson expands upon Detroit’s descriptive relativism.  As stated in their article, “MULTIPLICITY AS RESOURCE: A Combined Architectural Narrative”, Detroit provides a unique opportunity to study how the urban architect may engage the vast plurality of perceptions and beliefs that define a city, and how they can inform the future trajectory of its built environment.  As the infamous case study of our current international economic and social condition, it is fashionable to expound on what should be done with, what will become of, what happened to, Detroit.  As an object, Detroit is a land of multiple narratives, and in the vein of descriptive pluralism, all of these narratives are true.  (more…)

LEAPING OFF:NEW YORK CITY’S HIGHLINE

Wednesday, January 12th, 2011

shadowbox

EVALUATION CITY : Post Industrial’s Most Valuable Urbanism

Thursday, October 14th, 2010


The following text is an excerpt from an article entitled “EVALUATION CITY: Post Industrial’s Most Valuable Urbanism” that has been recently published in the latest MONU magazine.

To aid in the surplus of stressful societal situations that face the modern female, the 21st century woman can rely on a handful of helpful journals such as “Cosmopolitan” and “Glamour” to evaluate any relationship or affirm all major life decisions.  These lifestylist magazines will argue that there is no unique set of conditions, no singular relationship, and no unusual characteristics that can’t be quantified.  In support of these sweeping generalizations, many of the articles summarize their theories by incorporating a simplified quiz, a minimal test that helps the reader judge themselves, another human being, and the future success of their relationship.  Within a few short minutes, the contemporary lady can create her own personal compass to help guide her through modern relationships: whether that relationship is with her current spouse, potential boyfriend, frustrating boss, or annoying mother-in-law.

“How compatible are you and your spouse in bed?”
“Is he going to marry you?“
Should you leave your job?“

Ironically, these outrageously simple evaluation techniques are also commonly used to stereotype other modern conditions.  As seen in a plethora of media outlets, the “most livable city” is a ranking system usually completed by an accounting or financial firm that evaluates international cities against a series of pre-set criteria.  Each city is judged using their past year’s statistics, appraised, and then ranked against one another.   Depending upon the media’s audience, intentions, and desired outcomes, these standards vary slightly, factoring unique priorities into an otherwise biased economically-based set of standards.  In one example, Forbes combined income, crime statistics, unemployment, housing markets, and college graduate statistics with amicable weather AND professional sports team winnings to result in their list of “Top 10 Best Places to Live in the US.”  Simultaneously, Forbes also published the “Top 10 Worst Places to Live in the US” using the same questionable data combinations. (more…)

Deconstruction Detroit Discussion

Friday, September 3rd, 2010

Deconstruction Detroit: A [RE]generation Strategy from HAA on Vimeo.



Last week, over 150 people gathered at Recycle Here! for the most recent installment in the lecturesHAA series. The event brought together representatives from Architectural Salvage Warehouse, C3LL3C, Recycle Here!, University of Detroit Mercy, and Design Evolution Workshop to discuss Deconstruction as an approach to managing Detroit’s many vacant and abandoned buildings. Each panelist began with a brief presentation framing his specific role in and approach to the deconstruction process. The presentations were followed by a panel discussion which both affirmed the position of Deconstruction within Detroit, as well as exposed the challenges facing the industry here and elsewhere.

The conversation ranged from the techniques and tactics involved in dismantling structures, to its economic feasibility and related public policy. The dialogue exposed the negative ecological impact of traditional demolition practices and demonstrated how Deconstruction and recycling techniques offer a sustainable alternative. Yet it also exposed the obstacles facing the Deconstruction industry as it competes with demolition. Because it is a labor intensive process, Deconstruction generally takes longer and is therefore more costly than traditional practices. And so it was with both optimism toward deconstruction’s possibilities and a realistic understanding of its difficulties that the evening unfolded. Though it was clear it will be some time before Deconstruction becomes a mainstream alternative to demolition, the passion and enthusiasm of the panelists and audience alike were testament to a collective belief in the value of this burgeoning industry. (more…)

DETROIT / FLIP IT

Friday, May 21st, 2010

DETROIT FLIP IT

Detroit – Flip It

Flippin’ (or to Flip) is the process of manipulating and fashioning a sound into a beat. Sometimes this sample is manipulated so much that you can’t even tell where it came from. Still, there are other cases where a sample can be flipped, even while it contains its original identity. Flippin’ can also be the reinterpretation or reconceptualization of an established style, sound, practice, and/or theme.

Recent research initiatives at HAA revealed the necessity for a new approach, one that can more successfully address some of Detroit’s most notable challenges. This new approach should not only acknowledge our existing circumstances, but seek to leverage and then “flip” them into figurative and literal assets.  Since past conventional practices have contributed to our current situation, should we rely on these same practices to resolve our current conditions?  Further aggravating the perceived confusion, many in the national media still focus on perpetuating negative perceptions.  As designers, we have an immediate opportunity to shift these perceptions toward a more positive frame of mind, utilizing innovative design strategies that (re)present negative attributes as previously unrecognized positive opportunities.

Put simply, a negative perception can truly become positive.  Previously negative language implications can be transformed into provocative drivers for positive socioeconomic outcomes.  When applied on multiple fronts, these “flipped” perspectives can emerge into a clearly unified view of Detroit. (more…)

DETROIT : Scale of crisis = scale of intervention

Tuesday, May 4th, 2010

DRIWR 01: Detroit Metro Contaminated Sites

DRIWR03: AerialDRIWR02: Masterplan
DRIWR06DRIWR04DRIWR05

HYBRID URBANISM.
Landscape Urbanism advocates a purposeful discourse between ecological systems, human activities, and the post-industrial landscape, ultimately manifesting in the deliberate celebration of the urban void.  This celebration glorifies the interstitial, so that the void is inevitably romanticized by, and is necessary to, the burgeoning Landscape Urbanism profession. Reliance on the void introduces a basic set of dilemmas:  In order to focus on the space between buildings, there must be buildings; planning creative programming between infrastructural systems requires existing infrastructure; implementing a proposed hybrid ecology between urban eco-systems and human eco-systems requires human eco-systems.  All of these very specific examples result in a single common statement:  In order to have an urban void, there first needs to be an urban, or rather a recognizable urban density.

What if the relationship between building density and void are reversed and the void is now the primary urban component?  What does it mean to reclaim a contaminated post-industrial site within a post urban city, a city whose built fabric has devolved into vast stretches of rural landscape?  Operating within the current design process parameters, Landscape Urbanism succeeds primarily in high-density urban fabrics such as New York City, Boston, and Chicago.  In these cities, individual brownfield sites are easily identifiable as precious, rare interstitial spaces. These voids are ultimately reclaimed, remediated, and creatively stitched back into the dense urban fabric to be utilized by their host city.  In post-industrial cities such as Detroit however, the urban condition (building density) has dissolved as the metropolis has decentralized. Neither the city nor the suburbs sustain the density required to find the contaminated land valuable, and thus lack a desire to stitch these abandoned outposts into their community.  Combine all of these individual outposts together and the metropolitan region is scarred by larger swaths of contaminated land, further compartmentalizing dissipated downtowns from their thriving suburban counterparts. On the national scale, we can recognize a larger post-industrial megalopolis landscape: shrinking cities left to die back into a growing contaminated terrain.  For the City of Detroit, the void is now the majority on a multiplicity of scales. This presents the fundamental challenge of practicing a type of Landscape Urbanism appropriate to Detroit’s post urban condition.

With the Detroit River International Wildlife Refuge Gateway, Hamilton Anderson Associates (HAA), seeks to broaden the Landscape Urbanism discourse by implementing a strategic, multi-scalar design process that reexamines urban and redefines the void. (more…)

DETROIT TRANSIT: Part 2 : RECAST THE MYTH

Sunday, April 11th, 2010

lead-image

Transit Part 2 Image Alex Maclean01
Transit Part 2 Image Alex Maclean02Transit Part 2 Image Alex Maclean03

The American Dream has run out of gas. The car has stopped. It no longer supplies the world with its images, its dreams, its fantasies.-J.G. Ballard

Tall Tales.  The story of the American transportation infrastructure system is one of heroic planning, but also of equally heroic rhetoric. At each stage in its evolution – be it the canals and waterways of the Gallatin Plan, the Intercontinental Railways, or the Interstate Highway system – the connection between the pragmatic realities of steel and concrete and the cultural myths which support them has been tenuous at best. Yet each is inextricably linked to the other, and in many cases essential to its success. As we embark on the next national transit planning initiatives, these myths will inevitably become wrapped around a new set of objectives; providing meaning and purpose to the practical endeavors of transit planning. (more…)

DETROIT TRANSIT, Part 1

Wednesday, March 10th, 2010

lead

flash-preview.jpg
expressways
DSR-map_railservice-1941
1990 Regional Transit System

Whither goest thou, America, in thy shiny car in the night? – Jack Kerouac

Detroit is ironically the most and least likely place to discuss mass transit. Once the home of one of the nation’s most extensive streetcar systems (link to map), Detroit has become synonymous with decentralization, suburban expansion, and the dominance of the automobile.  Where human mobility was once limited by the location of rail lines, canals, and the limited travel range of other non-motorized forms of transportation, the car provided a universal form of personal transportation which could be used at virtually any geographic scale. Unfortunately, the success of the car came at the expense of all other modes of transportation, eventually leading Detroit and other cities toward an inefficient and unsustainable transit monoculture.

Recently, infrastructural failures in this country have gained national and international attention. With increasing national imperative, as well as efforts at the regional and local level, it appears mass transit is finally becoming a reality. High-speed rail development in Florida between Tampa, Orlando and Miami, and in California linking Sacramento, San Francisco and L.A., has been covered extensively throughout the media. Portland Oregon’s streetcar system has become a benchmark for urban transit in this country. And the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) has allocated substantial funds to the development of public transit systems, indicating a shift in support and investment toward sustainable car alternatives. As this transition occurs, however, it is important to consider not only the new forms of transportation infrastructure and technology that will be necessary, but also the relationship between these and existing development patterns. (more…)